Clearly writing our daily OK! Old School posts is one of our favorite pastimes here at, because we are all 90’s kids at heart. And ya know what? So are celebs! We got tons of our favorite stars to tell us who they were crushin’ on when they were teenagers, and it just made us love them even more because we so agree with their choices.

OK! Old School: Andrew Keegan is on Instagram

From Saved By the Bell to Jonathan Taylor Thomas (swoon), see whom celebs from Kristin Cavallari to Kevin and Danielle Jonas to Heather Dubrow picked in the gallery below!

OK! Exclusive: Hanson Reveals What It’s Like to Be Dads

Oh, and just FYI, one of the Real Housewives who answered our question took a major dig at the Kardashians while she was at it soooo keep clicking…

Photos: Bravolebrities Tell What Celebs Need Their Own Reality Show

Who was your celebrity crush when you were a teen? Which of these celebs’ crushes do you agree with the most? Tweet us your picks @OKMagazine!