It looks like Randy Jackson is winning this game because he has stuck it out on Idol for 12 seasons now! Yeah, dog! This year, Usher and Shakira are taking their seats in The Voice chairs while Nicki Minaj and Mariah Carey are being separated at the American Idol table by fellow newbie, Keith Urban. Do you think they'll flop like these other judges? You won't believe who else tried out the judging gig, so we're going to remind you. Check out the full gallery below!
Who are some of your favorite reality judges? Are you happy any of these celebs didn't last on their show? Tweet us your thoughts at @OKMagazine!