Ted finally found the mysterious Slutty Pumpkin on How I Met Your Mother last night in the form of Katie Holmes, but she didn't live up to his expectations.
Ted (Josh Radnor) tracks down the Slutty Pumpkin he met 10 years ago and tries to rekindle the romance he thought they once had.
And very quickly viewers learned that Katie will not be the mother.
"I like her. Okay? I really really like her. I just don't seem to like anything she says or does…" Ted tells his friends. "I have to break up with her, don't I?"
Did Katie's appearance on How I Met Your Mother live up to your expectations?
Watch a clip of Katie as the Slutty Pumpkin, below!