Be honest: The Black Swan was definitely a Halloween costume consideration in 2011. Natalie Portman's dramatic winged eye makeup is synonymous with the Oscar-winning performance.
Remember the days when Gossip Girl's Little J had more love for Blair Waldorf's spot on the Met steps than she did for black eyeliner? After that whole design fiasco with Agnes the rebel model, Jenny ditches her pretty pink cosmetics look for good and makes the super smokey eye a signature.
Before Molly Ringwald's character gave Allison a makeover, The Breakfast Club character was working a subtle smokey eye with little pizzazz and barely any mascara.
She may have been "best friends" with Regina George in grade school, but Mean Girls' Janis Ian was way edgier in the cosmetics department. We're referring to her lined lids, obviously—not the minty foot cream situation.
One Tree Hill's Glenda was instrumental in getting Lucas Scott to continue writing his book. Another thing she was good at? Rocking a shadow-covered lid and a vampy bold lip.
You may have focused your attention on his hair styling ability, but next time you're watching Edward Scissorhands, take a look at his intense burgundy lids.
Along with her piece-y pixie and piercings, The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo's Lisbeth Salander found her look in dark eye makeup.
C'mon! You've got to remember Dora Diamond from Loser. The character, played by Mena Sulvari and opposite to Jason Biggs, had a thing for charcoal shadow.
Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice—OK, we won't risk it. The guy was creepy, he was weirdly obsessed with Winona Ryder's character, and he had AMAZING eye makeup.
The Hunger Games' Katniss is truly one tough chick—that you know. And the girl (who happened to look like a total princess at her wedding) stayed true to her strong personality with grey metallic eyes.