Jennifer Aniston Plays Would You Rather & Picks Megan Fox Over Regis Philbin!

Would You Rather is always a fun game to play, but it's even more fun when Jennifer Aniston and Paul Rudd are playing it! The Wanderlust co-stars sat down with MTV's Josh Horowitz and participated in the game — whether they wanted to or not!

OK! GALLERY: JENNIFER ANISTON JOINED BY JUSTIN THEROUX & HER DAD AT HOLLYWOOD WALK OF FAME CEREMONY

Josh tried to make the questions difficult for the stars during his MTV interview. He made one option be an older star of their same gender and the other a younger star of their opposite gender.

Decisions, decisions.

"Paul, would you rather have sex with Betty White or George Clooney?" Josh asked.

Not wanting to insult either stars, Paul asked, "Can it be both?"

Aww. That's...sweet?

Jennifer, however, wasn't as kind.

OK! GALLERY: JENNIFER ANISTON & JUSTIN THEROUX WALK RED CARPET SEPARETELY AT WANDERLUST PREMIERE

Josh asked, "Jen, would you rather have sex with Regis Philbin or Megan Fox?"

"Megan Fox," Jen said with a laugh. "Sorry."

"That took no time at all," Paul joked. "You actually answered it."

"What was I going to think...I mean Reg," Jen explained.

"He's a national treasure," Paul argued.

"Yes, he is. But it's Reg," she said. "That seems, like, wrong. This isn't actually happening."

Who would you have chosen?

Watch the hilarious clip over at MTV.com!