OK!’s Rana Meyer and Derek Ivie break down your fave shows of the night!
One Tree Hill: "I knew that Nanny Carrie wasn’t going to go silently into the night when she departed last week. And I will admit that it was so predictable that as soon as Nathan stepped into the shower, Nanny Carrie would be stepping in right behind him and, of course, just as Haley walked in. Not surprisingly, Haley threw him out. But I really did feel bad for Nathan. He really didn’t do anything wrong. Yeah, he let Carrie kiss him and he didn’t look away when she went skinny-dipping and he should have told Haley right away. But I don’t think he cheated on Haley. And he messed up when he should have told Haley about the kiss. But that nanny is psycho. Especially messing with poor little Jamie’s head. I hope the situation doesn’t go too out of hand, because I’m a sucker for romance and I love that little family. In the meantime, as Brooke finally gets hot bartender Owen to go out with her and see what life is like for her in NYC, she gets a surprise from her past. They enter Brooke’s East Village apartment to find Rachel totally overdosing on the floor. So this is where Rachel has been for the past four years. Working for Brooke and partying in Manhattan; of course Rachel would get herself in trouble. So this is how they’ll get Rachel to reunite with the Tree Hill gang, forget about rehab, Brooke will just take her back to their hometown. Yeah, I can see that working, nothing cures drug addiction more than hanging out with your old high school pals. Rachel was not the only surprise from the past to pop up, Lucas and Nathan had to attend their dad Dan’s parole hearing. And all was going well until Lucas learned that Nathan had visited Dan. Nathan is just not doing good with the honesty right now. But Lucas still made a good case for Dan not to get parole. The man killed his uncle at point-blank range for god’s sake. But I have a sneaking suspicion that Dan will soon be reuniting with the Tree Hill gang as well." — Rana
The Biggest Loser: "This… episode… made… me… want… to… FALL ASLEEP! They have to stop making Loser two hours long! They have to! They never used to be and now they are every week! Do we really need to see every painstaking second of those weigh-ins? Get them on and off the scale! Just like Maggie did. She went up, got weighed-in and then got off! Not to mention that I can no longer stand the Blue Team. They were still crying from last week! Jay, I need you to calm down! You will see your brother in a few weeks! It’s okay! This guy doesn’t even miss his wife as much as he misses his brother! More like this poor guy doesn’t even know how to function because his brother has been such a bully! The temptation challenge was pretty cool. They could win money, eat calories or get a one pound pass from a mystery vending machine. Dan had the most money with $9500 and Kelly did the worst with only calories and no money or pass. The rest of them received one pound passes. Bernie also chose the "Gameplay" envelope for his Biggest Loser prize from the week before and was allowed to give one other person in the game immunity other than himself. Their trip back to the hospital? Yawn… The challenge had them dangling over a canyon to collect flags. The Blue Team won of course, and that was that. Thank the lord we didn’t have to see them enjoying their prize of the dog fighting planes. Bernie gives the immunity to Brittany because they have been together from the start. They weigh-in, and Kelly and Bernie are in the bottom two. Because Bernie is a bigger threat he is sent home. He was my favorite person on the show and of course, he’s leaving now! Where is my makeover show! Bring that back! Bernie looks great now! He has lost 108 lbs. since he left and he is still awesome!" — Derek