American Idol‘s top 11 took the stage again last night to perform all Elton John songs and Haley Reinhart earned the top praise from the judges for having the “best performance of the night!” Haley sang “Bennie and the Jets” with a lot of her sexy growling, but did you think it was the best performance?
Haley embraced the stage and started her performance on top of a piano before getting the audience to raise their hands up with her to the song.
“Yes that was it, Haley! That was it, Haley!” Jennifer Lopez said.
“For me, I know this is going to sound strange coming from me, best performance of the night right there!” Randy Jackson added. “Right there! Right there! You gave it up you deserve it.”
“Haley, it just goes to prove what a well-placed chorus will do,” Steven Tyler explained. “You. Sing. Sexy.”
Did you agree with the praise Haley received? Was it the best performance of the night?
Watch the Haley perform below!