It's easy to see where celebrities are coming from. If you were hot, rich, and famous, you'd want to marry a hot, rich, famous person, too! But these stars learned that the key to lasting romantic happiness was to pick a low-key, chill person—and keep it private.
Anne Hathaway rebounded from her luxurious lifestyle with rich con artist Raffaello Follieri with her now-husband, fellow actor Adam Shulman.
Jennifer Lopez seemingly only dated high-profile fellows like Ben Affleck and Marc Anthony, but she's happy these days with dancer Casper Smart.
Reese Witherspoon and Ryan Phillippe were really cute together—but after her divorce, she did alright by marrying agent Jim Toth.
Jessica Simpson had a reality show based around her first marriage, to Nick Lachey. This time around, she's keeping things chill with football player Eric Johnson.
Drew Barrymore married Tom Green and macked on Justin Long before making it official with art dealer Will Kopelman.
Julia Roberts romanced Lyle Lovett and Benjamin Bratt before her current marriage to camera man Danny Moder.
After Kate Winslet's divorce from director Sam Mendes, she found love again with Ned Rocknroll.
Jennifer Love Hewitt had several celeb boyfriends—notably Jamie Kennedy for awhile—before her marriage to mostly unknown co-star Brian Hallisay.