Gia Allemand – The Bachelor Season 14 – Jake Pavelka
America first fell in love with Gia Allemand on season 14 of The Bachelor with Jake Pavelka. The brunette beauty stole our hearts again with her back-to-back appearance on Bachelor Pad. You are greatly missed Gia and forever loved by Bachelor fans!
Emily Maynard – The Bachelor Season 15 – Brad Womack
Brad Womack missed out in season 15 on the gorgeous Emily Maynard. However the southern sweetheart gave love another try as she searched for Mr. Right as The Bachelorette.
Michelle Money – The Bachelor Season 15 – Brad Womack
Michelle Money had no problem letting Brad Woman know her true feelings for him. In the end, the beauty guru's agressive antics outweighed her ridiculously good looks.
Rozlyn Papa – The Bachelor Season 14 – Jake Pavelka
While Rozlyn Papa may have caused one of the most jaw-dropping moments in The Bachelor history, it's clear why Jake Pavelka kept the aspiring actress around.
Selma Alameri – The Bachelor Season 17 – Sean Lowe
We are still shocked that Selma Alameri only made it to the top 9 on Sean Lowe's season. We had her pegged for at least the final four!
Sarah Brice – The Bachelor Season 7 – Charlie O’Connell
All the way back in season 7, Sarah Brice and Charlie O'Connell fell in love. Their one-again-off-again relationship lasted for more than 5 years and really had Bachelor fans hoping their romance would last!
Shayne Lamas – The Bachelor Season 12 – Matt Grant
At only 22 years old, Shayne Lamas wowed British heartthrob Matt Grant . Sadly the couple broke up only four months later.
Victoria – The Bachelor Season 18 – Juan Pablo Galavis
Only time will tell Victoria's fate on Juan Pablo Galavis' season of The Bachelor, but we have a feeling the Brazilian bombshell will go far (if not win) the competition!
DeAnna Pappas – The Bachelor Season 11 – Brad Womack
DeAnna was shocked (and so were we) that Brad Womack did not choose anyone at the end of season 11. Later the Greek goddess found love again on The Bachelorette, but unfortunately the engagement did not last.
Ashley Hebert – The Bachelor Season 15 – Brad Womack
Ashley Hebert may not have found love with Brad Womack in season 15, but she did meet her future husband as The Bachelorette in 2011.
Elizabeth Kitt – The Bachelor Season 14 – Jake Pavelka
Elizabeth Kitt caused some tension with the girls in season 14, but ended up finding romance after the show with The Bachelorette alum Ty Brown.
Andi – The Bachelor Season 18 – Juan Pablo Galavis
Andi has both brains and beauty making her the perfect fit for Juan Pablo Galavis!
Catherine Giudici – The Bachelor Season 17 – Sean Lowe
Catherine Giudici is not only beautiful, bubbly and witty, but the future Mrs. Lowe!
Kacie Boguskie – The Bachelor Season 16 – Ben Flajnik
While Kacie Boguskie first appeared on Ben Flajnik's season, she later shocked fans by coming back for a shot at love with Sean Lowe.
Alexis – The Bachelor Season 18 – Juan Pablo Galavis
Alexis is a Florida native just like Juan Pablo Galavis. Will this be the bond that ties them together? Tune in this season to find out!
Samatha Levey – The Bachelor Season 16 – Ben Flajnik
Samantha Levey's elimination was confusing on so many levels. Was she really upset to be leaving Ben Flajnik or the producer she was rumored to have a crush on? Hmm.
Jillian Harris – The Bachelor Season 13 – Jason Mesnick
Jillian Harris was a fan favorite on Jason Mesnick's season of The Bachelor which made her the perfect Bachelorette in 2009!
AshLee Frazier- The Bachelor Season 17 – Sean Lowe
Never in a million years would we have seen AshLee Frazier's elimination reaction. But, the girl did have a fabulous look every episode from head-to-toe!
Jen Schefft – The Bachelor Season 3 – Andrew Firestone
On season three, Andrew Firestone got down on one knee asking Jen Schefft for her hand in marriage. While their relationship did not work out, she did go on to be The Bachelorette!
Tenley Molzahn – The Bachelor Season 14 – Jake Pavelka
Tenley Molzahn was one spot away from earning the final rose from Jake Pavelka. As you can expect, this caused an outroar from fans as Vienna took home the romantic proposal.
Ashley Spivey – The Bachelor Season 15 – Brad Womack
Ashley Spivey was America's sweetheart on Brad Womack's season. Too bad he didn't choose the New York City nanny!
Melissa Rycroft – The Bachelor Season 13 – Jason Mesnick
Melissa Rycroft's experience on The Bachelor may have been a wild ride, but it led her to gigs on Dancing With the Stars, Good Morning America and her own reality show!
Courtney Robertson – The Bachelor Season 16 – Ben Flajnik
Plain and simple, Courtney Robertson is the prettiest "villain" to ever appear on television. Plus, she landed a proposal from Ben Flajnik which naturally shocked Bachelor fans across the nation.
Ali Fedotowsky – The Bachelor Season 14 – Jake Pavelka
Remember when Ali Fedotowsky withdrew from the competition because of her job at Facebook? We will never forget her tearful goodbye with Jake Pavelka or her stint as The Bachelorette.
Desire Hartsock – The Bachelor Season 17 – Sean Lowe
Desiree Hartsock's exit on Sean Lowe's season of The Bachelor was basically the perfect audition tape to become The Bachelorette. If it wasn't for that limo ride, who knows if the fashion designer would have met her hunky fiancé Chris.
Trista Sutter – The Bachelor Season 1 – Alex Michel
Trista Sutter is basically the matriarch of The Bachelor franchise so naturally this list would not be complete without her!