The speculation started when Andrew took to Instagram to announce the baby boy is due May 13th.
“Now everyone can go see what or who Amber was doing on August 20, 2017,” an Amber Twitter parody wrote, as fans over Reddit and Twitter speculated it could be Matt's baby because the couple was on the rocks at the time of conception.
“She was still sleeping with Matt then and I know this because I was talking to that loser,” one fan commented on Twitter, as another wrote, “It seems really close between the time Amber was last with Matt and when she got with Andrew. I think there's definitely an overlap.”
Back in August 2017, Radar exclusively reported that two ex-girlfriends slapped Andrew with restraining orders. The first was granted for a period of three years, while the second was dismissed. He exclusively told Radar at the time, “This is jeopardizing our relationship, which tears my heart. She is still processing. Right now everything is up in the air.”
The source insisted, “It's definitely not his.”
However, Amber took things into her own hands! She responded to fans that sent her photos of previous news stories regarding the timeline of her relationships with Matt and Andrew and who the father could be. She wrote, "Me and Matt broke up in May lol."
What do you think of Amber's response? Let us know your thoughts!