Celebs Tell OK! Their Celebrity Crushes From When They Were Teens

Which former boy bander did Giuliana love so much that she literally sifted through his trash when she was a teen?

G was a major NKOTB fan! Like, really major. Here's what she said about her creepy obsession.

"I probably should never admit this but I had my mom for my birthday take me to Boston, to Dorchester and like, I think I went through Jordan Knight's trash. Or I tried. I went through someone’s trash, I don’t think it was his."

What were you looking for in there?

"Stuff. Anything. Like, old underwear, I didn’t care. But yeah, how sad is that! But I gotta be honest, like New Kids, this is when they were the most famous. So we bumped into other people going through their trash, who were looking for their homes. It was crazy. So I was a total hardcore NKOTB fan."

Which 90's heartthrob made Kristin Cavallari go pale in the face? Click to find out...

Devon Sawa! Kristin told us, "I was obsessed with Devon Sawa—I remember him from Casper. Gosh. I was in love with him. "

Which boy bander was Brande crushin' on back in the day? It was...

Ricky Martin! Brande told us, "Ricky Martin from Menudo. I used to have a Menudo poster on my wall and that was my big crush. I loved Ricky Martin. But that was back when I thought he liked girls (laughs)."

Which of the ladies from 'Vanderpump Rules' crushed hard on a guy from a very famous 90's show? Click away...

Kate Marie Maroney told us she went crazy for 'Home Improvement's JTT! She said, "Oh god! Jonathan Taylor Thomas I was obsessed with. And then later, Justin Timberlake and all the boy banders."

And speaking of boy banders, which one did Danielle Jonas crush on in the late 90's before she married her own guy from a boy band years later?

Joey Fatone from NSYNC! Kevin and Danielle told us:

Kevin: Her crush was Joey Fatone from NSYNC. Which was ironic because he was at our wedding.

Danielle: Kevin was getting a little tense when I was dancing with him at the wedding.

Kevin: Just a little bit, but I just had to think, 'You know what? This is MY wedding, I don't want anything to happen…' (laughs)

Which pin-up star was Tamra obsessed with in her teen years? And the winner is...

Leif Garrett! Tamra said, "Lief Garrett. You don’t even know who the hell that is. He was like in Teen Beat. I don’t even know who he was. I don’t think he was anything. He was kinda like the Kardashians! Ha!"

As a teen, who did the 'Pretty Little Liars' star want as her Romeo?

Leonardo Dicaprio, of course! Torrey said, "Like every other teenage girl from my time, when Romeo and Juliet came out, I don’t remember what grade I was in, but I did a 15 minute presentation on Leonardo Dicaprio (laughs) so I was definitely in love with him when I was young. I think he broke all of our hearts. That hair that was falling in his eyes. Oh god, stop. He was terrible. He did us all in."

Before he was selling homes, who did Ryan want to take home with him when he was younger?

Kelly Kapowsky, duh. Ryan told us, "Tiffany Amber Thiessen. She played Kelly on Saved By the Bell. I once wrote her a postcard and she wrote me back. It said may all your dreams come true...and then she kissed it."

James wasn't a teen too long ago, but regardless, which movie star did he fall hard for back then?

James loved...Hermione! He said, "Of course I had quite a few crushes. This industry has a lot of beautiful ladies. But I remember watching Harry Potter when I was really young and I was like, Hermione, Emma Watson, she was a cutie. But I think I might supercede that with maybe Eliza Dushku or a few other people now, but Emma's still a gorgeous, talented girl."

Who did Heather tell us she crushed on as a teen and whom she ended up actually kissing years later?

Scott Baoi! Heather said, " I totally had a crush on Scott Baio, and he ended up being my first on-screen kiss."