It might be the Sophie's Choice of lunchtime, but in honor of the premiere of Top Chef Duels, we put the stars to the test: grilled cheese or peanut butter and jelly?
Check out the video above where we caught up with the contestants and judges at the Top Chef Duels premiere event, presented by Bravo and Chase Sapphire Preferred. Surprisingly, the contest was closer than we thought it would be! See what judges Gail Simmons and Curtis Stone chose, as well as contestants like Richard Blais, Brooke Williamson and Tiffani Faison.
Top Chef Duels premieres tonight on Bravo at 10 p.m. ET.
Which sandwich do you choose? Which contestant would you want to make it for you? Tell us in the comments below or on Twitter @OKMagazine.