Bentley Williams made his return on The Bachelorette last night and finally Ashley Hebert told him off and moved on. But Jimmy Kimmel is still upset Ashley didn't realize he was "Satan" from the very beginning!
"Was there a specific moment when you realized Bentley was, in fact, Satan, the devil?" Jimmy asked Ashley on Jimmy Kimmel Live! via Skype.
"I think for the first time, they really showed what he was doing," Ashley replied from her home. "I don't remember an exact moment in the conversation, but he would always go back and forth between pretending to be interested and not being interested. And he did that the whole time."
"Yes, but he's been doing that through the whole show. You just didn't realize it when it was happening," Jimmy argued. "He has been doing this terrible thing. I can see how you wouldn't realize it because we were tipped off by those kind of interview segments where he was saying the things directly to the camera. But also when you watch it, maybe it's hindsight, you could just see he's just one of those guys that wants, even if it causes you pain, he wants to go ahead and make things 'right.' "
"Yes, I mean, you're right," Ashley agreed. "You're completely right."
"Thank you," Jimmy said.
"Being there, it was so different." Ashley said. "I promise you that."
"I bet you anything he stole the towels from the hotel room when he left!" Jimmy joked.
"Looking back, I can see it, but still... why did he come back? Why?" Ashley asked.
"Well, I think maybe he realized he was going to seem like Hitler/Bin Laden, and he thought he was going to make things better, when they actually made it worse!" Jimmy explained.
But Ashley doesn't regret telling all of the guys about her meeting with Bentley.
"I took a huge risk," she said, "but I don't regret it."
And Jimmy concluded he hopes J.P. is the winner!
Watch the Skype video, below!