NEWSIs Craig Conover Dating Again? Meet His Alleged New Flame Natalie Buffett
Is Craig Conover off the market? The 'Southern Charm' star is sparking romance rumors with his alleged new flame Natalie Buffett.
April 6 2025, Published 3:00 p.m. ET
While viewers tune in to the saga of Craig Conover and Paige DeSorbo’s unraveling romance on Summer House Season 9, the Southern Charm star has already hopped on the love train with a new mystery woman, sparking dating rumors with Natalie Buffett.
"I tend to date only one person at a time," Conover revealed to Andy Cohen on Watch What Happens Live on March 27.
“I’ve been seeing someone. I’ve been reminded that the universe works in crazy ways and everything happens for a reason,” he added.
Craig Conover might be dating Natalie Buffett after his split from Paige DeSorbo.
This door-opening comment has fans buzzing, but neither Conover nor Buffett officially confirmed their budding relationship.
Here’s everything you need to know about the woman who’s caught Conover’s eye, including her intriguing past with an NFL star.
Natalie Buffett, a civil engineering graduate, is no stranger to star-studded romances.
Buffett studied Civil Engineering at the Southern Methodist University from 2015 to 2019.
After snagging an internship at BGE, she climbed the career ladder to become the Director of Content and Strategy at OxeFit, where she currently shines, according to her LinkedIn profile.
Many speculated she may be related to music icon Jimmy Buffett, but it seems unlikely, with a savvy fan on TikTok pointing out that Natalie is not related to him.
The user said: "Natalie is NOT the heir to the Jimmy Buffett fortune. He has a wife – Janey [Buffett] and three children – Savanah [Buffett], Delaney [Buffett] and Cameron [Buffett]. Natalie is NOT an heir."
- Paige DeSorbo 'Felt She Needed to Speak Up' About Cheating Rumors After Split From Craig Conover Since He 'Didn’t Defend Her'
- 'What Is This Outfit?': Craig Conover Bashed for His Poor Fashion Taste After Paige DeSorbo Split
- 'What Is This Outfit?': Craig Conover Bashed for His Poor Fashion Taste After Paige DeSorbo Split
Want OK! each day? Sign up here!
Craig Conover dated Paige DeSorbo for three years.
Before Craig, Natalie was no stranger to romance, especially in the world of professional sports. She previously dated Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott, making headlines in July 2020 when she publicly celebrated his birthday on Instagram with sweet messages.
"Happy birthday my love! So proud of everything you’ve accomplished and overcome this past year," she gushed in a heartfelt post. The two shared a home — and three dogs — during their time together.
Natalie Buffett is not related to Jimmy Buffett.
After making a splash with Dak, who was lovingly referred to as her "cowboy," the duo split in 2022, right after Natalie joined him for the NFL Honors ceremony. Fast forward to December 2023, and Natalie was making waves once again, this time with MLB pitcher Jack Flaherty, as shown in a now-deleted photo of them sharing a kiss.
