When Chris Soules had to send Kaitlyn Bristowe, Becca Tilley or Whitney Bischoff home on Monday night’s epiosde, he seemed unsure of his final decision all throughout the rose ceremony. When Kaitlyn was left standing without a rose in her hand Chris told her, “This has been the most excruciating week of my life. I’m following my heart.” But The Bachelor star gave a different (and shocking!) explanation during The Women Tell All special!
After a romantic night in the fantasy suite, Kaitlyn seemed confident that she would be receiving a rose. “Chris seemed really into her the whole time,” a source told InTouch. “When she went home, it was a shock to everyone, especially Kaitlyn.”
So when Kaitlyn had her opportunity to confront the heartbreaker during the special, she didn’t hold back! “She asked Chris how he could blindside her like that,” the insider said.
- Stealing His Spot? Chris Harrison Reveals Which 'Bachelor' Alums Were After Coveted Hosting Gig
- Kaitlyn Bristowe Admits She Already 'Feels Married' To Jason Tartick, Dishes On Their 'Unique' Bond
- Former 'Bachelorette' Kaitlyn Bristowe Is Getting Ready For Her Wedding With Amazon's Handmade — Shop Her Collection
In a response that shocked even the audience, Prince Charming said, “I flipped a coin!”
CHRIS SOULES, BECCA
Everyone was of course stunned by the confession, but not as shocked as Whitney and Becca will be when they find out! The source said, “I can only imagine what the winner is going to think when she learns that he’s marrying her because a coin landed on tails."
Who do you think Chris will choose? Tell us in the comments below or tweet @OKMagazine!