Accuser Brian Evans Says Carrot Top's Medical Emergency Timeline 'Does Not Add Up' and Seeks New Police Review

Carrot Top accuser Brian Evans is calling on police to take another look at the timeline surrounding the comedian's September medical crisis, claiming the public account of what unfolded "does not add up," OKMagazine.com can reveal.

Evans, who is suing Carrot Top – real name Scott Thompson – said he wants the Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department to examine the circumstances surrounding the September 18 suicide attempt that left the longtime Las Vegas entertainer hospitalized.

The singer's request centers on what he claims are inconsistencies between the reported timeline, previous OK! stories, and the account allegedly provided to officers.

According to Evans' statement, reports describing the police account said Thompson's tour manager, Daniel O'Leary, told officers a news article broke at approximately 3:20 p.m. that day involving a lawsuit accusing the comedian of s----- misconduct.

O'Leary allegedly said Thompson became upset, indicated his shows would be stopped, and later sent him a message reading, "Done," before he became unreachable.

Police reportedly arrived at Thompson's home at approximately 4:21 p.m., and the entertainer was later found unconscious and transported to a hospital.

However, Evans claims the timeline raises questions because OK! had already published stories involving the litigation before September 18.

OK! reported on Evans' case on September 9. A separate September 16 report detailed a sworn declaration from Zachary DeFazio containing allegations against Thompson. Evans argues that means neither story would have been breaking for the first time at 3:20 p.m. on September 18.

"If any article upset him, it was Zachary DeFazio, and it was already out," Evans claimed.

Evans also pointed to a Las Vegas Review-Journal report stating Thompson had been seen at Finney's Crafthouse in Downtown Summerlin with two companions at approximately 2 p.m. that afternoon, roughly two hours before emergency personnel arrived at his residence.

He further cited previous attempts by a process server to access Thompson's residence, claiming the property's gate had repeatedly been closed during attempted service but was reportedly open on the afternoon of the medical emergency.

"It does not make sense," Evans said. "I believe this is spin control. I want the police to look at the whole day."

At a September 22 hearing, Circuit Judge Shari Africk-Olefson did not dismiss the case or make a finding that Evans caused Thompson's medical emergency.

Evans said he plans to provide authorities with supporting material, including process-server records, court documents, and previously published reports. Thompson was subsequently released from the hospital, and his representatives announced his return to the stage.

OK! has reached out to Thompson's representatives and the Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department for comment.