During the Wednesday, December 21, episode of the hit Bravo series, the Beauty Lab + Laser founder remained tight lipped about the source of her huge black eye and the scratches all over her body during the cast's trip to San Diego.
"I didn't say I don't remember how it happened," Gay said in a confessional, avoiding the big question. "I just said I'm not talking about it."
"It's first rule about fight club," she coyly pointed out.
After seemingly getting into a roe with someone during a rowdy night out with the cast, the Real Housewives: Ultimate Girls Trip alum said she did not want to discuss the matter.
- Jen Shah Claims Andy Cohen Is 'Still Butthurt' for Not Getting an Interview With Her Before Prison Sentence
- 'Bad Weather' Ahead? Whitney Rose Reveals What Ended Tight Friendship With 'RHOSLC' Costar Heather Gay
- Secrets, Rants & Lies: The Trailer For The Explosive Three Part 'Real Housewives Of Salt Lake City' Reunion Reveals Alleged Affairs, Threats & Explores The Fate Of Jen Shah
The Vida Tequila founder chimed in, insisting someone must have punched Gay in the face, to which the Bad Mormon author ominously responded, "Well, maybe somebody did, and they don't wanna talk about it."
Gay explained she did not want to ruin the rest of the vacation and that everyone should move on from the topic. However, later on in the episode, the Wild Rose Beauty founder told Barlow and Bui-Negrete that she believed it was Shah who socked her bestie in the face and that Gay wanted to protect the embattled reality star, as not to affect her ongoing legal troubles.
"Why do you not want to talk about it? Who are you trying to protect?" a producer asked Gay in a confessional, to which she responded, "Myself."
Although viewers were left without an answer, Marks emphasized the severity of the situation to production, saying, "Oh...my...god. Like, it seems like she was, you know, physically battered. It's really scary."