T.J. Holmes Admits He Started Falling in Love With Amy Robach While Still Married to Marilee Fiebig

The timeline we've all been waiting for — a description of when T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach's feelings turned romantic.

During the Thursday, February 15, episode of the scandalous couple's "Amy & T.J." podcast, the former Good Morning America stars reflected on the moment they knew a deeper connection had been formed while both Holmes and Robach had been married to their respective spouses, Marilee Fiebig and Andrew Shue — who, ironically enough, are reportedly dating.

"[I had] loved you for a long time," Holmes confessed while trying to nail down the moment he found himself aware he'd "been in love with you in this way when I knew that, and I’m thinking about it in my mind, like when did I know I’m in trouble, like uh-oh, this needs to be addressed. I can’t pinpoint. Post pandemic, 2020? When was that? D---, girl."

Helping her boyfriend piece together the timeline, Robach explained: "We started working together in 2020, like closely, we always worked together, but we actually shared an anchor desk fall of 2020."

Finally figuring out the order of events leading up to their official relationship, Holmes detailed, "it was early 2022, we didn’t start talking about it until much later, but when I thought there was an issue, for me, was 2022, going into spring, certainly summer, but spring of 2022 is when I’d say."

While the podcasters might have privately known about their newfound love in spring 2022, their affair wasn't exposed to the public until November 2022. Two months later, Holmes and Robach were axed from their jobs at ABC News.

Robach and Shue's divorce was finalized in March 2023, but they reportedly had been separated since August of the year prior.

Holmes didn't file to legally end his and Fiebig's marriage until December 2022, with their split later finalized in in October 2023.

Never miss a story — sign up for the OK! newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what OK! has to offer. It’s gossip too good to wait for!

While Holmes might have caught feelings for Robach while there was still a ring on both of their fingers, the former television personalities previously insisted there wasn't any infidelity in either of the two marriages.

"To be clear, we were outed as being in a relationship, but everyone else thought we were being outed as adulterers — being outed as cheating on our spouses — and it wasn’t the case,” Holmes alleged during the premiere episode of the lovebirds' podcast.

"We both at that point were in divorce proceedings," he claimed.

Robach and Shue never welcomed any kids together, however, the mom-of-two shares daughters Ava, 21, and Annie, 17, with her ex-husband Tim McIntosh.

Holmes and Fiebig share an 11-year-old daughter, Sabine. He is also a father to Jaiden and Brianna, whom he shares with his ex-wife Amy Ferson.