Love is the most confusing thing in the world—particularly when you look at the closely-documented, on-again, off-again relationship of pop princess Selena Gomez and Canadian crooner Justin Bieber. Their tumultuous romance has become the eighth wonder of the world, keeping Selenators and Beliebers glued to the pop superstars’ social media accounts.
Throughout their love-hate-to-love relationship, which began in 2009, Jelena’s relationship status was often reflected in their songwriting, going from “Can’t Keep My Hands To Myself” to lone “Wolves.” But “The Heart Wants What It Wants,” so the “Same Old Love” has been rekindled multiple times. In Justin’s oeuvre, he’s gone from “Boyfriend” to his “Baby” to the tearjerking “Baby I’ll be movin’ on,” and “Baby you should go and love yourself.”
Jelena’s inability to keep their romance away from the constant public scrutiny may have been their inconceivable downfall multiple times. But as soon as we’re sure they’re done, they’re spotted together again—Selena and Justin’s fishbowl relationship has become such a complicated saga that it’s nearly impossible to keep track of their dating status.
So are they or aren’t they? OK! takes a look back at the 64 best and worst moments of Selena Gomez and Justin Bieber’s drama-filled breakups and makeups spanning nearly a decade. Who knows? By the time you reach the end, they may even be back together!